| 2003- | Marilyn Evans |
| 1998-2003 | Gloria Roach Thomas (associate) |
| 1997- | Mark Nordell |
| 1993-98 | Marjory Shields (diaconal) |
| 1992-98 | Mike Dyrdal (associate) |
| 1989-92 | Marty Jones (associate) |
| 1989-92 | Dan Johnson (associate) |
| 1985-88 | Diane Koob (associate) |
| 1984-97 | Bruce Erikson |
| 1982-89 | Robert Zeimes (associate) |
| 1981-82 | Jack Harris (associate) |
| 1980-83 | Kathryn Schneider-Bryan (associate) |
| 1979-83 | Stuart Joransen (visitation) |
| 1978-79 | Gary Gottfried (youth ministry) |
| 1977-81 | Jo Campe (associate) |
| 1974-76 | Lawrence Foote (associate) |
| 1973-78 | Ronald J. Hillstrom (youth ministry) |
| 1972-77 | Wilbur Grose (associate) |
| 1968-73 | Thomas Wright (associate) |
| 1967-68 | Henry Johnson (associate) |
| 1963-67 | Robert D. Hunter (associate) |
| 1962-84 | Robert Bailey |
| 1959-62 | Sophus A. Norleman |
| 1957-67 | Edward Stodghill (visitation) |
| 1951-60 | Albert Schmitt |
| 1944-51 | Dennis Nyberg |
| 1942-44 | Willis Payfer |
| 1934-42 | Edward B. Cooney |
| 1920-34 | Henry J. Soltau |
| 1916-20 | John Walker |
| 1915-16 | C. H. Muse |
| 1914-15 | Chas. D. Blaker |
| 1912-14 | E. H. Nicholson (Associate) |
| 1909-12 | L.C. Benson |
| 1906-09 | George Mecklenburg (youth) |
| 1904-06 | George Ferguson |
| 1902-04 | John Wesley Mower |
| 1899-1902 | John L. Parmeter (visitation) |
| 1897-99 | David Tice |
| 1896-97 | A.F. Thompson (associate) |
| 1893-96 | Joseph R. Davis |
| 1892-93 | J.W. Powell (associate) |
| 1888-92 | David J. Higgens |
| 1886-88 | Dexter Smith |
| 1885-86 | H.J. Van Fossen |
| 1882-85 | M. B. Smith |
| 1881-82 | James Teter |
| 1880-81 | Levi Gleason |
| 1878-80 | Boyd Phelps |
| 1878-78 | J. W. Cornish |
| 1877-78 | E. O. Stoddard (died in mid year) |
| 1875-77 | L. P. Smith |
| 1873-75 | F. H. Tubbs |
| 1872-73 | David Brooks |
| 1871-72 | Henry Brook |
| 1867-71 | J. H. Macomber |
| 1866-67 | Jesse Smith |
| 1865-66 | J.D. Rich |
| 1864-65 | no record |
| 1863-64 | T. N. Berlin |
| 1862-63 | Levi Gleason |
| 1861-62 | John Hooper |
| 1860-61 | James Peet |
| 1859-60 | Oliver P. Light |
| 1858-59 | J. D. Rich |
| 1857-58 | John Hooper - First arrived as a missionary |
| 1856-57 | C. W. Harris |
| 1854-56 | J. W. Mills - Took the first class of people and organized them into a church. |
Copyright 2004 Brooklyn United Methodist Church. All rights reserved